Eddocu vs Stirling PDF: a document editor, or a self-hosted PDF toolbox

Short answer

Stirling PDF is a PDF toolbox with 60+ operations that you can run on your own server, mostly open source and free for individuals. Eddocu is a document editor for PDF, Word and PowerPoint with apps for phones too. Pick Stirling to process PDFs on your own infrastructure; pick Eddocu to write and edit documents on any device.

Related tools: Edit PDFSign PDFMerge PDF

Pick Eddocu if

  • You want to edit documents, not only process PDFs: Word files and slides too.
  • You work on an iPhone, iPad or Android phone as well as a computer.
  • You want an AI chat that edits the page in front of you.

Pick Stirling PDF if

  • You need to self-host, air-gap or audit the code of your PDF tools.
  • You run batch jobs, pipelines or an API over many PDFs.
  • You want 60+ PDF operations in one place, free for a small team.

Feature by feature

FeatureEddocuStirling PDF
PlatformsYes Windows, Mac, Linux, iPhone, iPad, Android and the webPartly Windows, Mac and Linux apps, the web, or your own server; no phone app
Works offlinePartly Yes in the apps on every platform; the web version needs a connectionPartly Desktop “Local Only” mode runs most tools offline; OCR, Office conversions and AI need its cloud or a server
OpensYes PDF, DOCX, PPTX; Pages and Keynote files on Mac and LinuxYes PDF; converts Office, image, HTML, Markdown, email and e-book files to PDF
Saves asYes PDF, DOCX, PPTX, HTMLYes PDF, PDF/A; converts PDFs to DOCX, PPTX, XLSX, images, HTML, Markdown and more
Edit an existing PDFYes Edit the text, images and pages of an existing PDFYes A text editor for existing text and images; Stirling warns fonts and layout can shift
Sign documentsYes Draw, type or upload a signature, ask others to sign, or sign with a .p12 certificate; the signing tools are in betaYes Visible signature (draw, type, upload) and separate certificate signing
AIYes Chat that drafts, rewrites and translates in the page; 100 credits a month free, more from $19.99 a monthPartly AI assistant on its cloud uses credits; self-hosted servers bring their own model
PriceYes Free for personal use, no ads; Pro $9.99 a month or $49.99 a yearYes Free for up to 5 users with 1,000 credits a month; Team $99 a month for 100 users
Account neededPartly Not to edit in the apps; a free account for the web version, cloud sync, sharing and AIPartly Not for the desktop app or the cloud’s manual tools; needed for AI and automation
Open sourceNo No, proprietaryPartly Open core: MIT, with proprietary editor, engine and cloud folders

What is different in practice

An editor for writing, not a toolbox for processing

Stirling PDF is built around operations on PDF files: merge, split, convert, redact, compress, run a pipeline. Eddocu is built around a page you write on: it opens a PDF, Word document or PowerPoint deck and you edit it directly, with an AI chat that proposes changes you accept or reject.

A PDF report open for editing in Eddocu, with the AI chat proposing three text changes and Accept and Reject buttons
A PDF open for editing; the AI chat changes the page and you accept or reject the result.

Phones and tablets

Stirling runs on Windows, Mac, Linux, in the browser or on your server, and has no phone app. Eddocu has apps for iPhone, iPad and Android with the same editor, and they work offline.

Eddocu on a phone, offline, finding the word toner inside a PDF invoice, a Word report and a contract
On a phone, offline: one search reads the names and every page of PDF and Word files.

Self-hosting and source code

Stirling can run on your own server, in Docker or Kubernetes, even air-gapped, and most of its code is open (MIT, with proprietary folders carved out). Eddocu is closed source and cannot be self-hosted; its apps keep your files on your device, but you cannot audit the code.

Page tools in both

Both merge, split and reorder PDFs. Stirling has more operations and an API for batches; Eddocu keeps each step as a version of the file so you can go back.

Eddocu PDF tools: four PDFs merged into one, then its pages dragged into a new order
Merging four PDFs and reordering the pages, with every step kept as a version.

Where Eddocu falls short

  • Eddocu imports a PDF, DOCX or PPTX into its own format and writes a new file when you save. Simple documents come back as they went in; complex layouts (dense multi-column pages, unusual fonts, embedded charts) can shift, so check the result before you send it.
  • Eddocu is closed source: you cannot read its code, audit it or host it on your own server.
  • Filling and adding PDF form fields happens in separate tools that are still in beta.
  • The web version needs an internet connection and a free account. Offline editing without an account is in the apps for Windows, Mac, Linux, iPhone, iPad and Android.
  • Eddocu has no API for batch PDF processing and no pipelines.

Questions people ask

Is Stirling PDF open source?

Mostly. Its licence is MIT, but the licence file carves out folders under a proprietary licence, including the desktop editor, the engine and the cloud parts, and Team and Enterprise features need a licence key. Eddocu is proprietary.

Can Stirling PDF edit text in a PDF?

Yes. Its PDF Text Editor changes existing text and images, and Stirling’s own guide says fonts and layout can shift slightly, so check the result. Eddocu edits PDF text too, with the same kind of caveat for complex layouts.

Which one works offline?

Stirling’s desktop app has a Local Only mode, but OCR, Office conversions, repair and AI need its cloud or a server. Eddocu’s apps edit offline on every platform; its web version needs a connection.

More comparisons